What Are People Saying About Dwell Home Team? Client Reviews & Testimonials for Nick and Christina Fitzer
If you’re searching for an honest review of Nick and Christina Fitzer before hiring a Gig Harbor real estate agent, you’re doing exactly what smart buyers and sellers do: checking what real clients have to say first. So we read through all 194 of our Google reviews (a perfect 5.0-star rating, going back a decade) and pulled out the themes that show up again and again, in clients’ own words.
Here’s what people are actually saying about Dwell Home Team.
The Short Answer: What People Are Saying About Dwell Home Team
Read enough of the 194 reviews back to back and the same themes surface constantly:
- Fast, reliable communication, even nights, weekends, and holidays
- Marketing and staging that trigger bidding wars and above-asking offers
- Skilled negotiation in competitive, multiple-offer situations
- Deep, neighborhood-level knowledge of Gig Harbor and the South Sound
- A proven track record with out-of-state and relocating clients
- Patient, honest guidance, even when the honest answer isn’t a sale
- Compassion during hard life transitions
- Clients who keep coming back for their 2nd, 3rd, even 6th transaction
Below, we break down each theme with direct quotes pulled from the reviews.
“They Respond Fast, Even on Nights, Weekends, and Holidays”
Responsiveness is the single most repeated theme in client testimonials for Dwell Home Team. Mary Koske reached out about a home valuation and said “they responded within an hour and it was a weekend!” Kjersti Johnson said the team was “so quick to respond, answered all of our questions, and couldn’t have been easier to work with.” Tarak Patel put it plainly: “They were available 24/7 and responded immediately to all my messages and questions.” Marta Webber added, “They were so quick to answer our calls and answered right away.”
“Their Marketing Sparked a Bidding War”
Sellers repeatedly point to marketing and staging as the reason their home sold fast and for more than expected. Nick Jeatran described “56 people at the first open house along with multiple offers out the gate,” adding his listing became “probably the highest viewed property on Redfin in Kitsap” that year. One Gig Harbor seller reported “86 showings in the first three days on the market” and “26 offers on day three alone,” ultimately accepting an offer 25% over asking with waived contingencies. Michael Wickens saw “3,200 views on Redfin in 4 days” and, after 15+ offers, accepted a deal 14% over list price. Danielle O’Leary‘s home, staged and professionally photographed, “sold in 12 hours.” Jacob Yount‘s home went under contract in 48 hours “while comparable homes continued to sit on market.”
“They Won the Deal in a Brutally Competitive Market”
Beyond marketing, clients consistently credit the team’s negotiation skill for winning homes against stiff competition. Katie Green had her at-list-price offer accepted over five competing offers (two of which were higher), calling Christina “an absolute boss” who “can make miracles happen.” Bryce Beard, another agent working opposite the team, said Nick and Christina “beat out an all-cash offer” for their buyers. Alon Orlev said Nick negotiated a deal on a home “that was initially over our budget,” never pressuring them, just laying out “the honest facts.”
“They Know These Neighborhoods Like Locals”
Hyper-local, neighborhood-level knowledge comes up constantly. Dianne Glynn and Mark Robinson both specifically credited the team’s deep knowledge of the Canterwood community in Gig Harbor. Ryan Blomster, buying a waterfront vacation home, praised their “real, on-the-ground knowledge: waterfront nuances (tides, dock and bulkhead considerations, sun exposure), commute patterns over the Narrows, and neighborhood-by-neighborhood dynamics.” Tobias called Nick “extremely knowledgable about the Gig Harbor market and marina life.”
“They Made Buying From Across the Country Feel Easy”
A huge number of reviews come from clients who bought or sold while living somewhere else entirely. Stewart Miller bought a home “from 3,000 miles away” and said the team “didn’t stop” helping even after closing, connecting him with contractors for renovations. Aika Crumrine purchased a house in Washington sight-unseen from Texas during COVID: “I still cannot believe we did it all online.” Webster Cavenee sold a home in 10 days while living in a different state. On a later purchase, he didn’t even see the new house in person before buying it. Courtney Richards and her husband were shown homes over detailed Zoom tours while living out of state and said they “never felt any pressure” despite months of searching.
“They Told Us the Truth, Even When It Wasn’t What We Wanted to Hear”
A theme that sets Dwell Home Team apart from a purely transactional agent: clients say the team gives honest answers, not a sales pitch. Mary Koske described how the team built a full cost breakdown that helped her decide to stay in her current home rather than move to California, advice that ran against their own financial interest. Sindhu Chandra said Nick is “honest, straightforward, and refreshingly candid about every property… he’ll spot what’s wrong, tell you what it’s really worth, and never sugarcoat it.” Whitney Peterson put it bluntly: Christina “just gets the job done, no bs.”
“They Showed Up With Real Compassion During a Hard Time”
Several reviews describe the team handling emotionally difficult situations with unusual care. Kendra Fling sold her home after a tree fell on it, making it unlivable, all while pregnant. The team managed an 8-month repair and design process and still secured multiple above-asking offers within days of listing. Andrew Cadmus, selling a home after a family member passed away, said Sue Darnell “read the room very well” during “an emotional and challenging time” and “didn’t try to BS me.” Kathy Derby, selling her family home, said the team “took the stress and burden of selling our home away at a time when we needed it most… if I could give 10 stars to Nick and Christina, I would.”
Clients Who Keep Coming Back
Maybe the clearest signal in all 194 reviews: how many clients used the team more than once. Wendy Twist used Christina for her sixth home purchase and third transaction with the team. Chris and Ann Guthrie sold their second home together with the Fitzers, noting the team “handled everything even while we were out of town.” D Peters worked with Sue Darnell across four transactions, calling her “an excellent advocate.” Craig Olsen said simply, “We have used Christina and Dwell Home Team for selling/buying multiple homes and can’t recommend them enough and will be life long customers.”
Why So Many Clients Choose Dwell Home Team
These aren’t isolated compliments scattered across a handful of five-star ratings. They’re the same handful of themes, repeated by hundreds of different clients, across nearly every transaction type: first-time buyers, sellers, out-of-state relocations, waterfront purchases, and emotionally difficult family sales. That consistency, across 194 reviews and seven years, is exactly what shows up when you search for a review of Nick and Christina Fitzer: fast communication, sharp local expertise, marketing that performs, skilled negotiation, and a team that treats each transaction like it matters personally.
Ready to Work With Gig Harbor’s Top-Rated Real Estate Team?
If you’re buying or selling in Gig Harbor, University Place, Tacoma, or the surrounding South Sound area, we’d love the chance to earn a review from you too. Reach out to us today to start the conversation.
Want to stay in the know for all this real estate?
We are fortunate to be the #1 most followed real estate brand on social media in our market. Visit Dwell’s Instagram to see that latest listing, market trends and local happenings.
